New York City 1-3 New England · Major League Soccer
Yankee Stadium · New York City 47 309 lugares
Árbitro: Jair Marrufo 21:00
Resumo do jogo
New England supera New York City por 3-1
Marcaram: Lee Nguyen (2'), Charlie Davies (38'), Kelyn Rowe (55'), David Villa (gp) (90'). Jogo a contar para Major League Soccer.
New York City New England 
- 90'+1 Golo de penálti David Villa
- 88' Cartão amarelo Diego Fagúndez
- 86' Cartão amarelo Tommy McNamara
- 77' Cartão amarelo Kwame Watson-Siriboe
- 75'
- 74'
- 67'
- 56'
- 55' Golo Kelyn Rowe (ass: Chris Tierney)
- 46'
- 45'+1
- 38' Golo Charlie Davies (ass: José Gonçalves)
- 2' Golo Lee Nguyen (ass: Charlie Davies)