Yankee Stadium · New York City 47 309 lugares
Árbitro: Baldomero Toledo 01:00
Columbus Crew supera New York RB por 3-1
Marcaram: Eddie Gaven (35'), Andy Iro (39'), Tony Tchani (81'), Emilio Rentería García (83'). Jogo a contar para Major League Soccer.
- 89' ↑ Duncan Oughton ↓ Jason Garey
- 85' Cartão amarelo · Tim Ream
- 83' Golo Emilio Rentería García
- 81' Golo Tony Tchani (ass: Carlos Mendes)
- 75' Cartão amarelo · Seth Stammler
- 71' ↑ Carlos Mendes ↓ Chris Albright
- 68' ↑ Emilio Rentería García ↓ Emmanuel Ekpo
- 68' ↑ John Wolyniec ↓ Jeremy Hall
- 65' ↑ Tony Tchani ↓ Siniša Ubiparipović
- 60' Cartão amarelo · Andy Iro
- 57' ↑ Jed Zayner ↓ Adam Moffat
- 52' Cartão amarelo · Adam Moffat
- 39' Golo Andy Iro (ass: Eddie Gaven)
- 35' Golo Eddie Gaven (ass: Frankie Hejduk)