Yankee Stadium · New York City 47 309 lugares
Árbitro: Kevin Stott 21:55
New York City e DC United empatam a 1
Marcaram: Steve Birnbaum (58'), David Villa (86'). Jogo a contar para Major League Soccer.
- 90'+1 ↑ Jared Jeffrey ↓ Luciano Acosta
- 81' ↑ J. Lewis ↓ James Sands
- 79' ↑ Kevin Ellis ↓ Ian Harkes